Children can concentrate less, but… they often have creative solutions for that

This sums it up very nicely:

Many children have a hard time with tasks requiring concentration, but are often good at discovering hidden ‘tricks’ to make the task easier. Spontaneous strategy changes help them to achieve this.

I think you now want to learn more about this study on learning behaviour in children that was published in the journal PloS ONE. Of course, if you are able to concentrate enough to read the full post…

From the press release:

Compared to adults, children cannot concentrate as well yet, remember less and have a relatively short attention span. This can be ascribed to the stage of cognitive development. As a result — as had been assumed so far — they have a disadvantage when solving tasks. However, a study by the Max Planck Research Group “NeuroCode — Neural and Computational Basis of Learning, Memory and Decision Making” at the Max Planck Institute for Human Development now shows that this broader attentional focus can also prove to be an advantage: children are good at processing less relevant information and using it to spontaneously find new and creative strategies when solving tasks.

Adults, too, show spontaneous strategy changes when solving tasks, similar to so-called “aha-moments” that make solving a task easier. The journal article shows that while children perform significantly worse when solving tasks using traditional strategies, such as focused attention, they are just as likely as adults to master tasks using spontaneous strategy shifts.

“Our results show that while children are often less focused and more easily distracted than adults, they are surprisingly flexible in discovering entirely new solutions,” says psychologist and neuroscientist Nicolas Schuck, group leader of the Max Planck Research Group “NeuroCode” at the Max Planck Institute for Human Development. “Especially considering their not fully developed ability to concentrate, these are important results for researching learning behavior in children,” Schuck added.

The study, which has been ongoing since 2013, used the following method to conduct research: 47 children between the ages of 8 and 10 and 39 young adults between the ages of 20 and 35 were asked to perform the same decision-making task. In this task, they were asked to determine the position of a pattern using two possible answers. The color of the pattern was not initially relevant for the correct answer, but began to correlate with the correct answer as the task progressed. If participants noticed this, they were able to solve the task much more efficiently and easily. Participants were not informed that there would be other factors influencing the possible solution strategies and could only identify them independently. The NeuroCode team at MPIB, in collaboration with researchers from Goethe University Frankfurt am Main, FernUniversität Hagen, Humbold University Berlin, UNSW Sydney, and PFH Göttingen, found the following results: Compared to the young adults, children generally performed significantly worse in solving the task. They committed more incorrect and premature answers. However, the proportion of children (27.5%) who discovered and used the helpful color strategy was very similar to that of the young adults (28.2%).

As long as children only used the initial strategies and rules available, which required concentration and persistence, they performed worse. However, a similar proportion of children and young adults discovered and used the color rule. Thus, although children performed worse in all areas of cognitive control, an almost equal proportion of them compared to the young adults were able to improve through an “aha moment,” and thus gained a similar performance advantage as the adult group.

The newfound knowledge around the “aha moment” is an important finding of the study. “Our findings provide evidence that educators, parents, and teachers should be less insistent on rigid rules by only teaching one concrete way to solve problems, but also value and encourage children’s broader attentional focus. Our findings show: We can have more confidence in children’s creative problem-solving strategies,” says Anika Löwe of the NeuroCode team and co-author of the study.

In the future, she says, in the field of cognitive developmental psychology there should be more research on creative processes rather than on the lack of concentration in children.

Abstract of the study:

Children often perform worse than adults on tasks that require focused attention. While this is commonly regarded as a sign of incomplete cognitive development, a broader attentional focus could also endow children with the ability to find novel solutions to a given task. To test this idea, we investigated children’s ability to discover and use novel aspects of the environment that allowed them to improve their decision-making strategy. Participants were given a simple choice task in which the possibility of strategy improvement was neither mentioned by instructions nor encouraged by explicit error feedback. Among 47 children (8—10 years of age) who were instructed to perform the choice task across two experiments, 27.5% showed a full strategy change. This closely matched the proportion of adults who had the same insight (28.2% of n = 39). The amount of erroneous choices, working memory capacity and inhibitory control, in contrast, indicated substantial disadvantages of children in task execution and cognitive control. A task difficulty manipulation did not affect the results. The stark contrast between age-differences in different aspects of cognitive performance might offer a unique opportunity for educators in fostering learning in children.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.