A new meta-analysis on growth mindset in teachers is rather sobering. While there has been a lot of research on student mindset, little is known about how this theory applies to teachers. After all, teachers play a crucial role in supporting students and structuring lessons, and their motivation can vary greatly. This can affect their professional performance and well-being. This is precisely what Lisa Bardach and colleagues’ meta-analysis sought to identify.
Their study examined the relationship between teachers’ growth mindset and various outcomes, such as their motivation (self-efficacy and performance goals), their own performance, their teaching strategies, and their students’ performance.
Overall, they found a small positive effect of teachers’ growth mindset on these outcomes. However, the effects are not always large or significant, and there are a few surprises among them.
First, the positive news. The analysis shows that teachers with a growth mindset have a higher sense of self-efficacy and more learning goals (rather than performance goals). This is consistent with what theory predicts: teachers with a growth mindset are more focused on growth and development for themselves and their students.
Further, among teaching strategies, there is a small but significant positive relationship between a growth mindset and the use of learning-centred structures in the classroom. This means teachers with a growth mindset are more likely to design their lessons to promote student growth and learning.
But now for the bad news: There was, in fact, no significant relationship between teachers’ growth mindsets and their test own performance. This suggests that a growth mindset alone may not be enough to produce better test scores.
Perhaps most strikingly, no meaningful relationship was also found between teachers’ mindsets and their students’ performance. This suggests that other factors, such as students’ backgrounds and concrete teaching methods, likely play a larger role in influencing student success.
The analysis also revealed some interesting differences between studies. For example, the researchers found that studies from the U.S. and Canada showed stronger effects than studies from Europe, which may be related to the popularity and implementation of the growth mindset concept in these regions.
Although teachers’ growth mindset can have certain positive effects, these effects are generally small. This means that although a growth mindset in teachers may be important for their motivation and certain teaching strategies, to be clear, it is not a panacea for improving their performance or that of their students.
Abstract of the meta-analysis:
The concept of growth mindset—an individual’s beliefs that basic characteristics such as intelligence are malleable—has gained immense popularity in research, the media, and educational practice. Even though it is assumed that teachers need a growth mindset and that both teachers and their students benefit when teachers adopt a growth mindset, systematic syntheses of the potential advantages of a growth mindset in teachers are lacking. Therefore, in this article, we present the first meta-analysis on teachers’ growth mindset and its relationships with multiple outcomes (50 studies, 81 effect sizes; N = 19,555). Multilevel analyses showed a small effect across outcomes. Statistically significant small-to-typical positive associations between teachers’ growth mindset and their motivation in terms of self-efficacy and mastery goals were observed in subgroup analyses. No statistically significant relationships were found with teachers’ performance-approach goals, teachers’ performance-avoidance goals, teachers’ performance on achievement tests, or student achievement. Teachers’ growth mindset was related to instructional practices in terms of mastery goal structures but unrelated to performance goal structures. Moderator analyses indicated that the dimensionality of the mindset measure (recoded from a fixed mindset to a growth mindset measure vs. assessed as a growth mindset), item referent and content of the mindset measure, publication status (published vs. unpublished), world region, educational level, and study quality influenced the strengths of some of the relationships. Overall, our findings extend knowledge about teachers’ mindset and add to the evidence base on teacher characteristics and their links to relevant outcomes.