Howard Gardner on his ‘multiple intelligences’: the theory is no longer current!

Howard Gardner was asked to reply to this question “Reflecting on your life, what has been your greatest accomplishment so far and why?” His reply – a short essay – can be read here.

A first interesting quote:

I termed the resulting categories “intelligences” rather than talents. In so doing I challenged those psychologists who believed that they owned the word “intelligence” and had a monopoly on its definition and measurement. If I had written about human talents, rather than intelligences, I probably would not have been asked to contribute to this volume.

I do understand this reasoning, but as we already discussed on this blog and in our book: the name intelligence includes a predictive element, while MI doesn’t.

Another interesting quote:

Nor, indeed, have I carried out experiments designed to test the theory. This has led some critics to declare that my theory is not empirical. That charge is baloney! The theory is not experimental in the traditional sense (as was my earlier work with brain-damaged patients); but it is strictly empirical, drawing on hundreds of findings from half-a-dozen fields of science.

This quote may raise some discussion, and actually I don’t agree with it neither. It’s not because you have a lot of sources that deliver you input for a theory, that this means you’re theory is tested.

But the most important quote:

At the same time, I readily admit that the theory is no longer current. Several fields of knowledge have advanced significantly since the early 1980s. Any reinvigoration of the theory would require a survey similar to the one that colleagues and I carried out thirty-five years ago. Whether or not I ever carry out such an update, I encourage others to do so.

And that is because I am no longer wedded to the particular list of intelligences that I initially developed. What I – and others, most notably Daniel Goleman and Robert Sternberg -have done is to undermine the hegemony over the concept of intelligence that was maintained for a century by adherents to a Spearman- Binet-Piaget concept of intelligence. I have no idea where the study of intelligence(s) will be a century from now, but I am confident that the field will recognize a plurality of skills, talents, and intelligences.



Filed under Education, Myths, Research, Review

14 responses to “Howard Gardner on his ‘multiple intelligences’: the theory is no longer current!

  1. Reblogged this on X, Y of Einstein? and commented:

    Deze Engelstalige blogpost is ondertussen een paar 1000 keer bekeken, en dat is wellicht niet zo verwonderlijk. Het siert Gardner dat hij dit geschreven heeft. Toch zal dit voor vele mensen die meervoudige intelligenties in het onderwijs als een verrassing komen.
    Concreet: de theorie is nooit door hem echt getest en volgens Gardner zelf is de theorie vandaag verouderd.

  2. Pingback: 2016 and The Economy Of Meaning | From experience to meaning...

  3. Pingback: Hoe kan je zien dat je handboek of cursus psychologie aan vervangen toe is? | X, Y of Einstein?

  4. Pingback: Hoe kan je zien dat je handboek of cursus psychologie aan vervangen toe is? | Blogcollectief Onderzoek Onderwijs

  5. Pingback: Zouden we maar niet beter stoppen met mythbusten? Over De Staat Van De Leerling… | X, Y of Einstein?

  6. Pingback: Zouden we maar niet beter stoppen met mythbusten? Over De Staat Van De Leerling… | Blogcollectief Onderzoek Onderwijs

  7. Pingback: Jordan Peterson puts it quite bluntly: The Theory of Multiple Intelligences Is Rubbish! | From experience to meaning...

  8. Pingback: Wetenschap en onderwijs | X, Y of Einstein?

  9. Pingback: Wetenschap en onderwijs (of ‘Onderwijs is niet zo eenvoudig als goeroes willen doen geloven’) | Blogcollectief Onderzoek Onderwijs

  10. Pingback: Why I am a bit annoyed with the mixed messages by Howard Gardner | From experience to meaning...

  11. Pingback: Another textbook study: how correct are introductory psychology textbooks? | From experience to meaning...

  12. Pingback: Fixed Mindset Strikes Again – The Examining Life

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.