What should we have done? (a short story about Active Clubs and more)

Image: https://www.middlebury.edu/institute/academics/centers-initiatives/ctec/ctec-publications/dangerous-organizations-and-bad-actors-active

“I’m really afraid for our club!”
I hear a young voice behind me say to his friends, and I realise that my headphones have finally run out of battery. The next time I take the train back from the Netherlands to Flanders, I really need to charge it better. Now I can’t help overhearing. They are sitting behind me. I’m not sure how many of them there are. Sitting opposite me is a young woman, somewhere in her early twenties, I’d guess.

“That broadcast is going to put us in danger.”

I have a pretty good idea what they’re talking about. Yesterday, like so many others, I also saw the Pano broadcast on our national broadcaster about Active Clubs. They are likely referring to the Dutch counterpart, Zembla.

“We are going to have to arm ourselves, take action.”

Did I really hear that sentence? Suddenly I’m glad I still have my headphones on, and I feel like pretending I’m still listening to music. I don’t, but I keep typing on my laptop, and I can’t help listening.

“A battle is coming, and we need to be ready, yes. Especially now, everything has to happen faster than expected.”

The train slows down for the next station. I hear some shuffling behind me. They gather their belongings, and it is clear this is the station where they have to leave the carriage. The coward in me wins out over curiosity. I don’t dare look up, even though I’d really like to see what the boys look like.

The train leaves again, and only now do I notice the young woman opposite me staring blankly ahead. I take off my headphones and ask, “You heard it too?”

She nods slowly, then: ‘What do you think?’ Funny how Dutch people always seem to think they need to address Flemish people more formally than they would each other.

“I don’t know. Pretty intense.”

“I’m afraid a broadcast like that will only make the polarisation in our society worse.”

“But… it’s important that this is brought to light,” I interject.

I see her hesitate. “You know, I am afraid for some of my friends. They will be the target of such Nazis; what’s more, they already have been. But only since yesterday have I known who was behind it. I recognised images in that broadcast. That brings it very close to home.”

I wanted to point out that the majority of society is not polarised. That social media and other media mainly amplify this, but I realise even before I say this that sometimes you only need a small group of hotheads for a lot of harm. 

“What do you think we can do?”

I honestly don’t really know. “Fighting back doesn’t seem like a good idea to me. Ignoring it certainly isn’t either. At the same time, I feel sorry for those boys. They might be living in a world they can’t quite understand. It is perhaps a way to find something to hold on to. A strong, tough story. I see plenty of those. And we all yearn for some form of community. Especially at that age.”

She pauses, then nods, and I realise that I have done anything but answer her question. I make another attempt anyway. “Are we offering them enough of an alternative? You can say, ‘don’t do this,’ but as a society, we offer little in return. There is less of a sense of community these days, and even less to hold on to. One of my sisters is a social worker and told me just last week how she notices how uncertain 17- and 18-year-olds are about the future. They don’t know what to study, out of fear that AI will make some, or even many, jobs redundant. And then there is the climate, the economic crisis, politics, how impossible it has become to buy a house, oh, the wars, and so on and so forth.”

No, I can’t give a good answer. Sometimes, as an older adult, you just have to remain silent every now and then. She smiles slightly and gathers her things.

Neither of us told anyone what we had just heard.

Note: No, this is not a true story. I didn’t take a train yesterday. I did speak to several people, people who will recognise fragments of sentences and events in this short story. As with my songs, I rarely write autobiographically. Instead, I drop autobiographical words, sentences and events into stories I’ve made up. For instance, my children’s book is completely made up, yet real-life educators do indeed appear in it. My books about education are not fictitious at all.

Leave a Reply