Can you make yourself happier by simply smiling? It sounds like one of those typical recommendations from self-help books. Feeling a bit down? Put a smile on your face, and your mood will follow naturally. I previously discussed research into how a teacher is allowed to fake enthusiasm. But is it also true that you feel happier when you smile? In a song, the answer would be yes, but new research, as always, adds nuance.
You might remember the famous pencil-in-the-mouth study by Strack and colleagues from 1988. Participants had to hold a pencil between their teeth, causing them to unconsciously use muscles that are also active when smiling, or between their lips, causing those muscles to become less active. The participants who held the pencil between their teeth subsequently rated cartoons as funnier. The study became a classic example of the facial feedback hypothesis, which harks back to Darwinian thought! Our facial expressions not only show how we feel, but they can also influence how we feel.
There was just one problem. In 2016, a large, pre-registered replication in 17 laboratories failed to replicate the original result. Yep, it is a well-known victim of the replication crisis. But… that wasn’t the end of the story. Later research, including a major international collaboration from 2022, did indeed find indications that intentionally smiling can make people a little happier. Remarkably, the evidence was stronger for intentionally adopting a smile than for the original pencil method.
So smiling makes you happier after all? Maybe. But another problem emerged. Consider people who work in shops, restaurants, or other service professions. They are expected to keep smiling throughout their working day. Research into what psychologists call emotional labour suggests that constantly having to display emotions you don’t necessarily feel is associated with a lower sense of well-being!
How can we reconcile both findings? A new study by Coles and colleagues, published in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, attempted to reconcile these seemingly contradictory findings.
The researchers recruited 1,201 participants for a preregistered experiment (nice!). Participants had to either consciously smile or let their faces react naturally. They did this while looking at positive images, such as kittens and flowers, or at negative images, such as animal abuse.
But the researchers added two more elements. Some participants had to smile only once, while others had to repeat the task ten times. The researchers also told some of the participants they could lose part of their compensation if they did not follow the instructions properly.
The researchers themselves identified three possible explanations they wanted to test:
- Smiling only helps in positive situations.
- It only works if you don’t have to smile constantly.
- The effect disappears when you force a person to smile.
So, what did they find? None of the three explanations was entirely correct.
In negative situations, participants who smiled once actually reported feeling slightly happier, regardless of whether there was a financial threat. However, that positive effect diminished when they had to smile repeatedly and disappeared when that repetition was combined with the threat of punishment.
Even more surprising was what happened in positive situations. Smiling voluntarily once did not make the participants happier. And when they had to smile repeatedly, or when a possible punishment loomed, they even reported less happiness. Furthermore, the researchers found that smiling in positive situations could amplify feelings of anger, especially when participants had to smile repeatedly under the threat of punishment.
So, smiling can make you happier, but apparently also less happy. Context plays a role, as does how often you need to smile. Before we conclude that employers should stop asking their staff to smile, I must first mention a few important limitations.
Firstly, the effects were generally small, and the experiment lasted only a short time. Smiling ten times during an online experiment is, of course, not the same as being friendly to customers for eight hours a day.
You can also question the comparison. Participants who were required to smile had to consciously control their facial expressions. The control group could react naturally. Could the negative effect be partly due to the effort or annoyance of controlling one’s face, rather than the smiling itself? The researchers mention this possibility themselves.
But a preregistered study that didn’t turn out as the researchers expected still has significant credibility. And the study also made me smile. Spontaneously, that is.