A new study on smartphones and sleep shows a striking difference between boys and girls

We know from several studies that, on average, girls feel less comfortable in their own skin than boys. Just yesterday, I discussed on Flemish radio how girls also appear to report feeling lonely more often, based on this recent study. Why this is the case is a difficult question, and we don’t yet have a conclusive answer. Social media is often cited as a possible explanation, but the story is likely more complex. A new study by Mathew and colleagues adds an interesting piece to the puzzle. This time, it’s about sleep.

The researchers monitored the smartphone use of 218 American adolescents aged 13 to 18. Instead of asking the teenagers how much time they spent on their smartphones, they actually recorded it. They did so for an average of 17.5 days. The teenagers used their smartphones for an average of 6.19 hours per day, including 2.56 hours for social media. The researchers also asked them about their sleep using a questionnaire.

Especially among girls?

As expected, the researchers found a link between smartphone use and sleep. Evening and nighttime use, in particular, was associated with falling asleep later and sleeping less. But… for girls, an extra hour of smartphone use between 8 pm and 11 pm was associated with falling asleep an average of 82 minutes later and sleeping 71 minutes less. These associations were even stronger for social media. For boys, the researchers found no statistically significant results for these specific associations. Interestingly, girls did not spend more time on their smartphones than boys on average.

How can we explain this? The researchers suggest that social interactions via smartphones may more often lead to rumination or emotional arousal among girls. Mind you, this is a hypothesis, but their research does suggest that there may be more to the story than the amount of screen time alone.

A piece of a larger puzzle?

I find this particularly interesting in light of the differences in well-being and loneliness between boys and girls. We know that sleep and psychological well-being are related. Could sleep, then, be one of the mechanisms linking smartphone use to girls’ well-being? Possibly, but we need to be careful.

First, sleep was not measured objectively but through self-report. Second, the sample was relatively small. And third, perhaps most importantly, this study shows associations, not causal relationships. Perhaps young people sleep less because they use their smartphones, but perhaps young people who have trouble sleeping actually use their smartphones more often. Moreover, the authors did not directly investigate the link with loneliness or psychological well-being. That’s a link I’m making in this blog post!

One thing does seem clear: not all screen time is the same, and its relationship with sleep may not be the same for everyone either.

Leave a Reply