Bring back the chalkboard? Teachers drawing diagrams is better than showing pre-made ones

Writing stuff with chalk on a blackboard, how old fashioned. But maybe sometimes still a good option, as this new study by shows students learn much more when listening to teachers’ talk while they draw diagrams rather than when teachers explained and showed pre-made diagrams. Not really surprisingly the effect was primarily the case for students with lower prior knowledge.

Does this means we should bring back the blackboard? No, you can do this with any kind of device, such as smartboards. Do note that in the experiment both approaches actually where shown in a video, making the study relevant for any kind of instruction, be it IRL or e.g. through video for a flipped classroom approach.

Abstract of the study:

In 4 experiments, participants viewed a short video-based lesson about how the Doppler effect works. Some students viewed already-drawn diagrams while listening to a concurrent oral explanation, whereas other students listened to the same explanation while viewing the instructor actually draw the diagrams by hand. All students then completed retention and transfer tests on the material. Experiment 1 indicated that watching the instructor draw diagrams (by viewing the instructor’s full body) resulted in significantly better transfer test performance than viewing already-drawn diagrams for learners with low prior knowledge (d = 0.58), but not for learners with high prior knowledge (d = −0.24). In Experiment 2, participants who watched the instructor draw diagrams (by viewing only the instructor’s hand) significantly outperformed the control group on the transfer test, regardless of prior knowledge (d = 0.35). In Experiment 3, participants who watched diagrams being drawn but without actually viewing the instructor’s hand did not significantly outperform the control group on the transfer test (d = −0.16). Finally, in Experiment 4, participants who observed the instructor draw diagrams with only the instructor’s hand visible marginally outperformed those who observed the instructor draw diagrams with the instructor’s entire body visible (d = 0.36). Overall, this research suggests that observing the instructor draw diagrams promotes learning in part because it takes advantage of basic principles of multimedia learning, and that the presence of the instructor’s hand during drawing may provide an important social cue that motivates learners to make sense of the material.

Advertisements

3 Comments

Filed under Education, Research, Technology

3 responses to “Bring back the chalkboard? Teachers drawing diagrams is better than showing pre-made ones

  1. I love it, I love it better than any new kind of technology 🙂

  2. I think it is important for the students to see the process so when a teacher draws the diagram, the student is able to follow and is able to formulate questions because they know exactly where their issues lie.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s